From 22719c659625a4a57aa00294b5b02c96c51762d4 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: dgp Date: Mon, 6 Nov 2017 00:10:21 +0000 Subject: Test case for Bug 5d65e65036. --- tests/pkg.test | 10 ++++++++++ 1 file changed, 10 insertions(+) diff --git a/tests/pkg.test b/tests/pkg.test index b935a3f..10b4732 100644 --- a/tests/pkg.test +++ b/tests/pkg.test @@ -518,6 +518,16 @@ test pkg-2.52 {Tcl_PkgRequire procedure, picking best stable version} { set x } {1.3} +test pkg-2.53 {Tcl_PkgRequire procedure, picking best stable version} { + package forget t + foreach i {1.2b1 1.1} { + package ifneeded t $i "set x $i; package provide t $i" + } + set x xxx + package require t + set x +} {1.1} + test pkg-3.1 {Tcl_PackageCmd procedure} { -- cgit v0.12 From a7b6d6094829c332ba8c551876a64b0226148c93 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: aku Date: Mon, 13 Nov 2017 18:58:16 +0000 Subject: Ticket [5d65e65036]. My fix. Do not skip the second check for stable versions even when the main check fails. Avoided radical changes to the structure (kept single search loop, with selection after). --- generic/tclPkg.c | 91 ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++-------------------- 1 file changed, 58 insertions(+), 33 deletions(-) diff --git a/generic/tclPkg.c b/generic/tclPkg.c index 52f33c3..d3dd584 100644 --- a/generic/tclPkg.c +++ b/generic/tclPkg.c @@ -349,7 +349,7 @@ PkgRequireCore( Interp *iPtr = (Interp *) interp; Package *pkgPtr; PkgAvail *availPtr, *bestPtr, *bestStablePtr; - char *availVersion, *bestVersion; + char *availVersion, *bestVersion, *bestStableVersion; /* Internal rep. of versions */ int availStable, code, satisfies, pass; char *script, *pkgVersionI; @@ -395,6 +395,7 @@ PkgRequireCore( bestPtr = NULL; bestStablePtr = NULL; bestVersion = NULL; + bestStableVersion = NULL; for (availPtr = pkgPtr->availPtr; availPtr != NULL; availPtr = availPtr->nextPtr) { @@ -408,58 +409,82 @@ PkgRequireCore( continue; } - + + /* Check satisfaction of requirements before considering the current version further. */ + if (reqc > 0) { + satisfies = SomeRequirementSatisfied(availVersion, reqc, reqv); + if (!satisfies) { + ckfree(availVersion); + availVersion = NULL; + continue; + } + } + if (bestPtr != NULL) { int res = CompareVersions(availVersion, bestVersion, NULL); /* - * Note: Use internal reps! + * Note: Used internal reps in the comparison! */ - if (res <= 0) { + if (res > 0) { /* - * The version of the package sought is not as good as the - * currently selected version. Ignore it. + * The version of the package sought is better than the + * currently selected version. */ - - ckfree(availVersion); - availVersion = NULL; - continue; + goto newbest; } - } - - /* We have found a version which is better than our max. */ - - if (reqc > 0) { - /* Check satisfaction of requirements. */ + } else { + newbest: + /* We have found a version which is better than our max. */ - satisfies = SomeRequirementSatisfied(availVersion, reqc, reqv); - if (!satisfies) { - ckfree(availVersion); - availVersion = NULL; - continue; - } + bestPtr = availPtr; + CheckVersionAndConvert(interp, bestPtr->version, &bestVersion, NULL); } - bestPtr = availPtr; - - if (bestVersion != NULL) { - ckfree(bestVersion); + if (!availStable) { + ckfree(availVersion); + availVersion = NULL; + continue; } - bestVersion = availVersion; - /* - * If this new best version is stable then it also has to be - * better than the max stable version found so far. - */ + if (bestStablePtr != NULL) { + int res = CompareVersions(availVersion, bestStableVersion, NULL); + + /* + * Note: Used internal reps in the comparison! + */ - if (availStable) { + if (res > 0) { + /* + * This stable version of the package sought is better + * than the currently selected stable version. + */ + goto newstable; + } + } else { + newstable: + /* We have found a stable version which is better than our max stable. */ bestStablePtr = availPtr; + CheckVersionAndConvert(interp, bestStablePtr->version, &bestStableVersion, NULL); } - } + ckfree(availVersion); + availVersion = NULL; + } /* end for */ + + /* + * Clean up memorized internal reps, if any. + */ + if (bestVersion != NULL) { ckfree(bestVersion); + bestVersion = NULL; + } + + if (bestStableVersion != NULL) { + ckfree(bestStableVersion); + bestStableVersion = NULL; } /* -- cgit v0.12 From 9f6573581348d2a8ceb4647ad9781d35644aee8b Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: dgp Date: Tue, 14 Nov 2017 17:09:49 +0000 Subject: Repair lost of broken [package prefer] testing. --- tests/package.test | 125 ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++----------- 1 file changed, 100 insertions(+), 25 deletions(-) diff --git a/tests/package.test b/tests/package.test index faa15ec..bb938b8 100644 --- a/tests/package.test +++ b/tests/package.test @@ -20,18 +20,19 @@ if {"::tcltest" ni [namespace children]} { ::tcltest::loadTestedCommands catch [list package require -exact Tcltest [info patchlevel]] -testConstraint testpreferstable [llength [info commands testpreferstable]] - # Do all this in a slave interp to avoid garbaging the package list set i [interp create] tcltest::loadIntoSlaveInterpreter $i {*}$argv +load {} Tcltest $i interp eval $i { namespace import -force ::tcltest::* -package forget {*}[package names] +#package forget {*}[package names] set oldPkgUnknown [package unknown] package unknown {} set oldPath $auto_path set auto_path "" + +testConstraint testpreferstable [llength [info commands testpreferstable]] test package-1.1 {pkg::create gives error on insufficient args} -body { ::pkg::create @@ -575,15 +576,23 @@ test package-3.44 {Tcl_PkgRequire: exact version matching (1578344)} -setup { package forget demo } -result {version conflict for package "demo": have 1.2.3, need exactly 1.2} test package-3.50 {Tcl_PkgRequire procedure, picking best stable version} -constraints testpreferstable -setup { + interp create child + load {} Tcltest child + child eval { testpreferstable package forget t set x xxx + } } -body { + child eval { foreach i {1.4 3.4 4.0a1 2.3 2.4 2.2} { package ifneeded t $i "set x $i; package provide t $i" } package require t set x + } +} -cleanup { + interp delete child } -result {3.4} test package-3.51 {Tcl_PkgRequire procedure, picking best stable version} -setup { package forget t @@ -621,28 +630,51 @@ test pkg-3.53 {Tcl_PkgRequire procedure, picking best stable version} -constrain test package-4.1 {Tcl_PackageCmd procedure} -returnCodes error -body { package } -result {wrong # args: should be "package option ?arg ...?"} -test package-4.2 {Tcl_PackageCmd procedure, "forget" option} { +test package-4.2 {Tcl_PackageCmd procedure, "forget" option} -setup { + interp create child +} -body { + child eval { package forget {*}[package names] package names -} {} -test package-4.3 {Tcl_PackageCmd procedure, "forget" option} { + } +} -cleanup { + interp delete child +} -result {} +test package-4.3 {Tcl_PackageCmd procedure, "forget" option} -setup { + interp create child +} -body { + child eval { package forget {*}[package names] package forget foo -} {} + } +} -cleanup { + interp delete child +} -result {} test package-4.4 {Tcl_PackageCmd procedure, "forget" option} -setup { + interp create child + child eval { package forget {*}[package names] set result {} + } } -body { + child eval { package ifneeded t 1.1 {first script} package ifneeded t 2.3 {second script} package ifneeded x 1.4 {x's script} lappend result [lsort [package names]] [package versions t] package forget t lappend result [lsort [package names]] [package versions t] + } +} -cleanup { + interp delete child } -result {{t x} {1.1 2.3} x {}} test package-4.5 {Tcl_PackageCmd procedure, "forget" option} -setup { + interp create child + child eval { package forget {*}[package names] + } } -body { + child eval { package ifneeded a 1.1 {first script} package ifneeded b 2.3 {second script} package ifneeded c 1.4 {third script} @@ -650,6 +682,9 @@ test package-4.5 {Tcl_PackageCmd procedure, "forget" option} -setup { set result [list [lsort [package names]]] package forget a c lappend result [lsort [package names]] + } +} -cleanup { + interp delete child } -result {{a b c} b} test package-4.5.1 {Tcl_PackageCmd procedure, "forget" option} -body { # Test for Bug 415273 @@ -668,28 +703,55 @@ test package-4.7 {Tcl_PackageCmd procedure, "ifneeded" option} -body { test package-4.8 {Tcl_PackageCmd procedure, "ifneeded" option} -body { package ifneeded t xyz } -returnCodes error -result {expected version number but got "xyz"} -test package-4.9 {Tcl_PackageCmd procedure, "ifneeded" option} { +test package-4.9 {Tcl_PackageCmd procedure, "ifneeded" option} -setup { + interp create child +} -body { + child eval { package forget {*}[package names] list [package ifneeded foo 1.1] [package names] -} {{} {}} + } +} -cleanup { + interp delete child +} -result {{} {}} test package-4.10 {Tcl_PackageCmd procedure, "ifneeded" option} -setup { - package forget t + interp create child + child eval { + package forget {*}[package names] + } } -body { + child eval { package ifneeded t 1.4 "script for t 1.4" list [package names] [package ifneeded t 1.4] [package versions t] + } +} -cleanup { + interp delete child } -result {t {script for t 1.4} 1.4} test package-4.11 {Tcl_PackageCmd procedure, "ifneeded" option} -setup { - package forget t + interp create child + child eval { + package forget {*}[package names] + } } -body { + child eval { package ifneeded t 1.4 "script for t 1.4" list [package ifneeded t 1.5] [package names] [package versions t] + } +} -cleanup { + interp delete child } -result {{} t 1.4} test package-4.12 {Tcl_PackageCmd procedure, "ifneeded" option} -setup { - package forget t + interp create child + child eval { + package forget {*}[package names] + } } -body { + child eval { package ifneeded t 1.4 "script for t 1.4" package ifneeded t 1.4 "second script for t 1.4" list [package ifneeded t 1.4] [package names] [package versions t] + } +} -cleanup { + interp delete child } -result {{second script for t 1.4} t 1.4} test package-4.13 {Tcl_PackageCmd procedure, "ifneeded" option} -setup { package forget t @@ -702,18 +764,31 @@ test package-4.13 {Tcl_PackageCmd procedure, "ifneeded" option} -setup { test package-4.14 {Tcl_PackageCmd procedure, "names" option} -body { package names a } -returnCodes error -result {wrong # args: should be "package names"} -test package-4.15 {Tcl_PackageCmd procedure, "names" option} { +test package-4.15 {Tcl_PackageCmd procedure, "names" option} -setup { + interp create child +} -body { + child eval { package forget {*}[package names] package names -} {} + } +} -cleanup { + interp delete child +} -result {} test package-4.16 {Tcl_PackageCmd procedure, "names" option} -setup { + interp create child + child eval { package forget {*}[package names] + } } -body { + child eval { package ifneeded x 1.2 {dummy} package provide x 1.3 package provide y 2.4 catch {package require z 47.16} lsort [package names] + } +} -cleanup { + interp delete child } -result {x y} test package-4.17 {Tcl_PackageCmd procedure, "provide" option} -body { package provide @@ -1251,11 +1326,9 @@ proc prefer {args} { } } -test package-13.0 {package prefer defaults} -constraints testpreferstable -setup { - testpreferstable -} -body { +test package-13.0 {package prefer defaults} -body { prefer -} -result stable +} -result [expr {[string match {*[ab]*} [package provide Tcl]] ? "latest" : "stable"}] test package-13.1 {package prefer defaults} -body { set ::env(TCL_PKG_PREFER_LATEST) stable ;# value not relevant! prefer @@ -1272,23 +1345,25 @@ test package-14.1 {bogus argument} -returnCodes error -body { test package-15.0 {set, keep} -constraints testpreferstable -setup { testpreferstable -} -body {package prefer stable} -result stable +} -body {package prefer} -result stable test package-15.1 {set stable, keep} -constraints testpreferstable -setup { testpreferstable -} -body {prefer stable} -result {stable stable} +} -body {package prefer stable} -result stable test package-15.2 {set latest, change} -constraints testpreferstable -setup { testpreferstable -} -body {prefer latest} -result {stable latest} +} -body {package prefer latest} -result latest test package-15.3 {set latest, keep} -constraints testpreferstable -setup { testpreferstable } -body { - prefer latest latest -} -result {stable latest latest} + package prefer latest + package prefer latest +} -result latest test package-15.4 {set stable, rejected} -constraints testpreferstable -setup { testpreferstable } -body { - prefer latest stable -} -result {stable latest latest} + package prefer latest + package prefer stable +} -result latest rename prefer {} -- cgit v0.12