path: root/tests/httpPipeline.test

# httpPipeline.test
#
#	Test HTTP/1.1 concurrent requests including
#	queueing, pipelining and retries.
#
# Copyright (C) 2018 Keith Nash <kjnash@users.sourceforge.net>
#
# See the file "license.terms" for information on usage and redistribution
# of this file, and for a DISCLAIMER OF ALL WARRANTIES.

package require tcltest 2
namespace import -force ::tcltest::*

package require http 2.9

set sourcedir [file normalize [file dirname [info script]]]
source [file join $sourcedir httpTest.tcl]
source [file join $sourcedir httpTestScript.tcl]

# ------------------------------------------------------------------------------
# (1) Define the test scripts that will be used to generate logs for analysis -
#     and also define the "correct" results.
# ------------------------------------------------------------------------------

proc ReturnTestScriptAndResult {ca cb delay te} {

    switch -- $ca {
	1     {set start {
	    START
	    KEEPALIVE 0
	    PIPELINE  0
	}}

	2     {set start {
	    START
	    KEEPALIVE 0
	    PIPELINE  1
	}}

	3     {set start {
	    START
	    KEEPALIVE 1
	    PIPELINE  0
	}}

	4     {set start {
	    START
	    KEEPALIVE 1
	    PIPELINE  1
	}}

	default {
	    return -code error {no matching script}
	}
    }

    set middle "
	    [list DELAY $delay]
    "

    switch -- $cb {
	1     {set end {
	    GET a
	    GET b
	    GET c
	    GET a
	    STOP
	    }
	    set resShort {1 ? ? ?}
	    set resLong  {1 2 3 4}
	}

	2     {set end {
	    GET a
	    HEAD b
	    GET c
	    HEAD a
	    HEAD c
	    STOP
	    }
	    set resShort {1 ? ? ? ?}
	    set resLong  {1 2 3 4 5}
	}

	3     {set end {
	    HEAD a
	    GET b
	    HEAD c
	    HEAD b
	    GET a
	    GET b
	    STOP
	    }
	    set resShort {1 ? ? ? ? ?}
	    set resLong  {1 2 3 4 5 6}
	}

	4     {set end {
	    GET a
	    GET b
	    GET c
	    GET a
	    POST b address=home code=brief paid=yes
	    GET c
	    GET a
	    GET b
	    GET c
	    STOP
	    }
	    set resShort {1 ? ? ? 5 ? ? ? ?}
	    set resLong  {1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9}
	}

	5     {set end {
	    POST a address=home code=brief paid=yes
	    POST b address=home code=brief paid=yes
	    POST c address=home code=brief paid=yes
	    POST a address=home code=brief paid=yes
	    POST b address=home code=brief paid=yes
	    POST c address=home code=brief paid=yes
	    POST a address=home code=brief paid=yes
	    POST b address=home code=brief paid=yes
	    POST c address=home code=brief paid=yes
	    STOP
	    }
	    set resShort {1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9}
	    set resLong  {1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9}
	}

	6     {set end {
	    POST a address=home code=brief paid=yes
	    GET b address=home code=brief paid=yes
	    POST c address=home code=brief paid=yes
	    GET a address=home code=brief paid=yes
	    GET b address=home code=brief paid=yes
	    POST c address=home code=brief paid=yes
	    POST a address=home code=brief paid=yes
	    HEAD b address=home code=brief paid=yes
	    GET c address=home code=brief paid=yes
	    STOP
	    }
	    set resShort {1 ? 3 ? ? 6 7 ? ?}
	    set resLong  {1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9}
	}

	7     {set end {
	    GET b address=home code=brief paid=yes
	    POST a address=home code=brief paid=yes
	    GET a address=home code=brief paid=yes
	    POST c address=home code=brief paid=yes
	    GET b address=home code=brief paid=yes
	    HEAD b address=home code=brief paid=yes
	    POST c address=home code=brief paid=yes
	    POST a address=home code=brief paid=yes
	    GET c address=home code=brief paid=yes
	    STOP
	    }
	    set resShort {1 2 ? 4 ? ? 7 8 ?}
	    set resLong  {1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9}
	}

	8     {set end {
	    # Telling the server to close the connection.
	    GET a
	    GET b close=y
	    GET c
	    GET a
	    GET b
	    GET c
	    GET a
	    GET b
	    GET c
	    STOP
	    }
	    set resShort {1 ? 3 ? ? ? ? ? ?}
	    set resLong  {1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9}
	}

	9     {set end {
	    # Telling the server to close the connection.
	    GET a
	    POST b close=y address=home code=brief paid=yes
	    GET c
	    GET a
	    GET b
	    GET c
	    GET a
	    GET b
	    GET c
	    STOP
	    }
	    set resShort {1 2 3 ? ? ? ? ? ?}
	    set resLong  {1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9}
	}

	10     {set end {
	    # Telling the server to close the connection.
	    GET a
	    GET b close=y
	    POST c address=home code=brief paid=yes
	    GET a
	    GET b
	    GET c
	    GET a
	    GET b
	    GET c
	    STOP
	    }
	    set resShort {1 ? 3 ? ? ? ? ? ?}
	    set resLong  {1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9}
	}

	11    {set end {
	    # Telling the server to close the connection twice.
	    GET a
	    GET b close=y
	    GET c
	    GET a
	    GET b close=y
	    GET c
	    GET a
	    GET b
	    GET c
	    STOP
	    }
	    set resShort {1 ? 3 ? ? 6 ? ? ?}
	    set resLong  {1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9}
	}

	12    {set end {
	    # Telling the server to delay before sending the response.
	    GET a
	    GET b delay=1
	    GET c
	    GET a
	    GET b
	    STOP
	    }
	    set resShort {1 ? ? ? ?}
	    set resLong  {1 2 3 4 5}
	}

	13    {set end {
	    # Making the server close the connection (time out).
	    GET a
	    WAIT 2000
	    GET b
	    GET c
	    GET a
	    GET b
	    STOP
	    }
	    set resShort {1 2 ? ? ?}
	    set resLong  {1 2 3 4 5}
	}

	14    {set end {
	    # Making the server close the connection (time out) twice.
	    GET a
	    WAIT 2000
	    GET b
	    GET c
	    GET a
	    WAIT 2000
	    GET b
	    GET c
	    GET a
	    GET b
	    GET c
	    STOP
	    }
	    set resShort {1 2 ? ? 5 ? ? ? ?}
	    set resLong  {1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9}
	}

	15    {set end {
	    POST a address=home code=brief paid=yes
	    POST b address=home code=brief paid=yes close=y delay=1
	    POST c address=home code=brief paid=yes delay=1
	    POST a address=home code=brief paid=yes close=y
	    WAIT 2000
	    POST b address=home code=brief paid=yes delay=1
	    POST c address=home code=brief paid=yes close=y
	    POST a address=home code=brief paid=yes
	    POST b address=home code=brief paid=yes close=y
	    POST c address=home code=brief paid=yes
	    STOP
	    }
	    set resShort {1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9}
	    set resLong  {1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9}
	}

	16    {set end {
	    POST a address=home code=brief paid=yes
	    GET b address=home code=brief paid=yes
	    POST c address=home code=brief paid=yes close=y
	    GET a address=home code=brief paid=yes
	    GET b address=home code=brief paid=yes close=y
	    POST c address=home code=brief paid=yes
	    WAIT 2000
	    POST a address=home code=brief paid=yes
	    HEAD b address=home code=brief paid=yes close=y
	    GET c address=home code=brief paid=yes
	    STOP
	    }
	    set resShort {1 ? 3 4 ? 6 7 ? 9}
	    set resLong  {1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9}
	}

	17    {set end {
	    GET b address=home code=brief paid=yes
	    POST a address=home code=brief paid=yes
	    GET a address=home code=brief paid=yes
	    POST c address=home code=brief paid=yes close=y
	    GET b address=home code=brief paid=yes
	    HEAD b address=home code=brief paid=yes close=y
	    POST c address=home code=brief paid=yes
	    WAIT 2000
	    POST a address=home code=brief paid=yes
	    WAIT 2000
	    GET c address=home code=brief paid=yes
	    STOP
	    }
	    set resShort {1 2 3 4 5 ? 7 8 9}
	    set resLong  {1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9}
	}


	18    {set end {
	    REPOST 0
	    GET a
	    WAIT 2000
	    POST b address=home code=brief paid=yes
	    GET c
	    GET a
	    STOP
	    }
	    set resShort {1 2 ? ?}
	    set resLong  {1 2 3 4}
	    # resShort is overwritten below for the case ($te == 1).
	}


	19    {set end {
	    REPOST 0
	    GET a
	    WAIT 2000
	    GET b address=home code=brief paid=yes
	    GET c
	    GET a
	    STOP
	    }
	    set resShort {1 2 ? ?}
	    set resLong  {1 2 3 4}
	}


	20    {set end {
	    POSTFRESH 1
	    GET a
	    WAIT 2000
	    POST b address=home code=brief paid=yes
	    GET c
	    GET a
	    STOP
	    }
	    set resShort {1 3 ?}
	    set resLong  {1 3 4}
	}


	21    {set end {
	    POSTFRESH 1
	    GET a
	    WAIT 2000
	    GET b address=home code=brief paid=yes
	    GET c
	    GET a
	    STOP
	    }
	    set resShort {1 2 ? ?}
	    set resLong  {1 2 3 4}
	}

	22    {set end {
	    GET a
	    WAIT 2000
	    KEEPALIVE 0
	    POST b address=home code=brief paid=yes
	    KEEPALIVE 1
	    GET c
	    GET a
	    STOP
	    }
	    set resShort {1 3 ?}
	    set resLong  {1 3 4}
	}


	23    {set end {
	    GET a
	    WAIT 2000
	    KEEPALIVE 0
	    GET b address=home code=brief paid=yes
	    KEEPALIVE 1
	    GET c
	    GET a
	    STOP
	    }
	    set resShort {1 3 ?}
	    set resLong  {1 3 4}
	}

	24    {set end {
	    GET a
	    KEEPALIVE 0
	    POST b address=home code=brief paid=yes
	    KEEPALIVE 1
	    GET c
	    GET a
	    STOP
	    }
	    set resShort {1 ? ?}
	    set resLong  {1 3 4}
	}


	25    {set end {
	    GET a
	    KEEPALIVE 0
	    GET b address=home code=brief paid=yes
	    KEEPALIVE 1
	    GET c
	    GET a
	    STOP
	    }
	    set resShort {1 ? ?}
	    set resLong  {1 3 4}
	}

	default {
	    return -code error {no matching script}
	}
    }


    if {$ca < 3} {
	# Not Keep-Alive.
        set result "Passed all sanity checks."

    } elseif {$ca == 3} {
        # Keep-Alive, not pipelined.
        set result {}
        append result "Passed all sanity checks.\n"
        append result "Have overlaps including response body:\n"

    } else {
        # Keep-Alive, pipelined: ($ca == 4)
        set result {}
        append result "Passed all sanity checks.\n"
        append result "Overlap-free without response body:\n"
        append result "$resShort"
    }

    # - The special case of test *.18*-testEof needs test results to be
    #   individually written.
    # - These test -repost 0 when there is a POST to apply it to, and the server
    #   timeout has not been detected.
    if {($cb == 18) && ($te == 1)} {
        if {$ca < 3} {
	    # Not Keep-Alive.
	    set result "Passed all sanity checks."

	} elseif {$ca == 3 && $delay == 0} {
	    # Keep-Alive, not pipelined.
            set result [MakeMessage {
		|Problems with sanity checks:
		|Wrong sequence for token ::http::2 - {A B C D X X X}
		|- and error(s) X
		|Wrong sequence for token ::http::3 - {A X X}
		|- and error(s) X
		|Wrong sequence for token ::http::4 - {A X X X}
		|- and error(s) X
		|
		|Have overlaps including response body:
		|
	    }]

	} elseif {$ca == 3} {
	    # Keep-Alive, not pipelined.
            set result [MakeMessage {
		|Problems with sanity checks:
		|Wrong sequence for token ::http::2 - {A B C D X X X}
		|- and error(s) X
		|
		|Have overlaps including response body:
		|
	    }]

	} elseif {$delay == 0} {
	    # Keep-Alive, pipelined: ($ca == 4)
            set result [MakeMessage {
		|Problems with sanity checks:
		|Wrong sequence for token ::http::2 - {A B C D X X X}
		|- and error(s) X
		|Wrong sequence for token ::http::3 - {A X X}
		|- and error(s) X
		|Wrong sequence for token ::http::4 - {A X X X}
		|- and error(s) X
		|
		|Overlap-free without response body:
		|
	    }]

	} else {
            set result [MakeMessage {
		|Problems with sanity checks:
		|Wrong sequence for token ::http::2 - {A B C D X X X}
		|- and error(s) X
		|
		|Overlap-free without response body:
		|
	    }]

        }
    }

    return [list "$start$middle$end" $result]
}

# ------------------------------------------------------------------------------
#  Proc MakeMessage
# ------------------------------------------------------------------------------
# WHD's one-line command to generate multi-line strings from readable code.
#
# Example:
#   set blurb [MakeMessage {
#            |This command allows multi-line strings to be created with readable
#            |code, and without breaking the rules for indentation.
#            |
#            |The command shifts the entire block of text to the left, omitting
#            |the pipe character and the spaces to its left.
#   }]
# ------------------------------------------------------------------------------

proc MakeMessage {in} {
    regsub -all -line {^\s*\|} [string trim $in] {}
    # N.B. Implicit Return.
}


proc ReturnTestScript {ca cb delay te} {
    lassign [ReturnTestScriptAndResult $ca $cb $delay $te] script result
    return $script
}

proc ReturnTestResult {ca cb delay te} {
    lassign [ReturnTestScriptAndResult $ca $cb $delay $te] script result
    return $result
}


# ------------------------------------------------------------------------------
# (2) Command to run a test script and use httpTest to analyse the logs.
# ------------------------------------------------------------------------------

namespace import httpTestScript::runHttpTestScript
namespace import httpTestScript::cleanupHttpTestScript
namespace import httpTest::cleanupHttpTest
namespace import httpTest::logAnalyse
namespace import httpTest::setHttpTestOptions

proc RunTest {header footer delay te} {
    set num [runHttpTestScript [ReturnTestScript $header $footer $delay $te]]
    set skipOverlaps 0
    set notPiped    {}
    set notIncluded {}

    # --------------------------------------------------------------------------
    # Custom code for specific tests
    # --------------------------------------------------------------------------
    if {$header < 3} {
        set skipOverlaps 1
        for {set i 1} {$i <= $num} {incr i} {
	    lappend notPiped $i
        }
    } elseif {$header > 2 && $footer == 18 && $te == 1} {
        set skipOverlaps 1
        if {$delay == 0} {
	    # Transaction 1 is conventional.
	    # Check that transactions 2,3,4 are cancelled.
	    set notPiped {1}
	    set notIncluded $notPiped
        } else {
	    # Transaction 1 is conventional.
	    # Check that transaction 2 is cancelled.
	    # The timing of transactions 3 and 4 is uncertain.
	    set notPiped {1 3 4}
	    set notIncluded $notPiped
	}
    } elseif {$footer in {20 22 23 24 25}} {
	# Transaction 2 uses its own socket.
	set notPiped    2
	set notIncluded $notPiped
    } else {
    }
    # --------------------------------------------------------------------------
    # End of custom code for specific tests
    # --------------------------------------------------------------------------


    set Results [logAnalyse $num $skipOverlaps $notIncluded $notPiped]
    lassign $Results msg cleanE cleanF dirtyE dirtyF
    if {$msg eq {}} {
        set msg "Passed all sanity checks."
    } else {
        set msg "Problems with sanity checks:\n$msg"
    }

    if 0 {
        puts $msg
        puts "Overlap-free including response body:\n$cleanF"
        puts "Have overlaps including response body:\n$dirtyF"
        puts "Overlap-free without response body:\n$cleanE"
        puts "Have overlaps without response body:\n$dirtyE"
    }

    if {$header < 3} {
        # No ordering, just check that transactions all finish
        set result $msg
    } elseif {$header == 3} {
        # Not pipelined - check overlaps with response body.
        set result "$msg\nHave overlaps including response body:\n$dirtyF"
    } else {
        # Pipelined - check overlaps without response body.  Check that the
        # first request, the first requests after replay, and POSTs are clean.
        set result "$msg\nOverlap-free without response body:\n$cleanE"
    }
    set ::nTokens $num
    return $result
}


# ------------------------------------------------------------------------------
# (3) VERBOSITY CONTROL
# ------------------------------------------------------------------------------
# If tests fail, run an individual test with -verbose 1 or 2 for diagnosis.
# If still obscure, uncomment #Log and ##Log lines in the http package.
# ------------------------------------------------------------------------------

setHttpTestOptions -verbose 0

# ------------------------------------------------------------------------------
# (4) Define the base URLs used for testing.  Each must have a query string.
# ------------------------------------------------------------------------------
# - A HTTP/1.1 server is required.  It should be configured to provide
#   persistent connections when requested to do so, and to close these
#   connections if they are idle for one second.
# - The resource must be served with status 200 in response to a valid GET or
#   POST.
# - The value of "page" is always specified in the query-string. Different
#   resources for the three values of "page" allow testing of both chunked and
#   unchunked transfer encoding.
# - The variables "close" and "delay" may be specified in the query-string (for
#   a GET) or the request body (for a POST).
#   - "delay" is a numerical value in seconds, and causes the server to delay
#     the response, including headers.
#   - "close", if it has the value "y", instructs the server to close the
#     connection ater the current request.
# - Any other variables should be ignored.
# ------------------------------------------------------------------------------

namespace eval ::httpTestScript {
    variable URL
    array set URL {
        a  http://test-tcl-http.kerlin.org/index.html?page=privacy
        b  http://test-tcl-http.kerlin.org/index.html?page=conditions
        c  http://test-tcl-http.kerlin.org/index.html?page=welcome
    }
}


# ------------------------------------------------------------------------------
# (5) Define the tests
# ------------------------------------------------------------------------------
# Constraints:
# - serverNeeded - the URLs defined at (4) must be available, and must have the
#                  properties specified there.
# - duplicate    - the value of -pipeline does not matter if -keepalive 0
# - timeout1s    - tests that work correctly only if the server closes
#                  persistent connections after one second.
#
# Server timeout of persistent connections should be 1s.  Delays of 2s are
# intended to cause timeout.
# Servers are usually configured to use a longer timeout: this will cause the
# tests to fail.  The "2000" could be replaced with a larger number, but the
# tests will then be inconveniently slow.
# ------------------------------------------------------------------------------

#testConstraint serverNeeded 1
#testConstraint timeout1s 1
#testConstraint duplicate 1

# ------------------------------------------------------------------------------
#  Proc SetTestEof - to edit the command ::http::KeepSocket
# ------------------------------------------------------------------------------
# The usual line in command ::http::KeepSocket is "    set TEST_EOF 0".
# Whether the value set in the file is 0 or 1, change it here to the value
# specified by the argument.
#
# It is worth doing all tests for both values of the argument.
#
# test 0  - ::http::KeepSocket is unchanged, detects server eof where possible
#           and closes the connection.
# test 1  - ::http::KeepSocket is edited, does not detect server eof, so the
#           reaction to finding server eof can be tested without the difficulty
#           of testing in the few milliseconds of an asynchronous close event.
# ------------------------------------------------------------------------------

proc SetTestEof {test} {
    set body [info body ::http::KeepSocket]
    set subs "    set TEST_EOF $test"
    set count [regsub -line -all -- {^\s*set TEST_EOF .*$} $body $subs newBody]
    if {$count != 1} {
        return -code error {proc ::http::KeepSocket has unexpected form}
    }
    proc ::http::KeepSocket {token} $newBody
    return
}

for {set header 1} {$header <= 4} {incr header} {
    if {$header == 4} {
	setHttpTestOptions -dotted 1
	set match glob
    } else {
	setHttpTestOptions -dotted 0
	set match exact
    }

    if {$header == 2} {
        set cons0 {serverNeeded duplicate}
    } else {
        set cons0 serverNeeded
    }

    for {set footer 1} {$footer <= 25} {incr footer} {
        foreach {delay label} {
	       0 a
	       1 b
	       2 c
	       3 d
	       5 e
	       8 f
	      12 g
	     100 h
	     500 i
	    2000 j
	} {
	  foreach te {0 1} {
	    if {$te} {
	        set tag testEof
	    } else {
	        set tag normal
	    }
	    set suffix {}
	    set cons $cons0

	    # ------------------------------------------------------------------
	    # Custom code for individual tests
	    # ------------------------------------------------------------------
	    if {$footer in {18}} {
		# Custom code:
		if {($label eq "j") && ($te == 1)} {
		    continue
		}
		if {$te == 1} {
		    # The test (of REPOST 0) is useful if tag is "testEof"
		    # (server timeout without client reaction).  The same test
		    # has a different result if tag is "normal".

		    set suffix " - extra test for -repost 0 - ::http::2 must be"
		    append suffix " cancelled"
		    if {($delay == 0)} {
			append suffix ", along with  ::http::3  ::http::4 if"
			append suffix " the test creates these before ::http::2"
			append suffix " is cancelled"
		    }
		} else {
		}
	    } elseif {$footer in {19}} {
		set suffix " - extra test for -repost 0"
	    } elseif {$footer in {20 21}} {
		set suffix " - extra test for -postfresh 1"
		if {($footer == 20)} {
		    append suffix " - ::http::2 uses a separate socket"
		    append suffix ", other requests use a persistent connection"
		}
	    } elseif {$footer in {22 23 24 25}} {
		append suffix " - ::http::2 uses a separate socket"
		append suffix ", other requests use a persistent connection"
	    } else {
	    }

	    if {($footer >= 13 && $footer <= 23)} {
		# Test use WAIT and depend on server timeout before this time.
		lappend cons timeout1s
	    }
	    # ------------------------------------------------------------------
	    # End of custom code.
	    # ------------------------------------------------------------------

            set name "pipeline test header $header footer $footer delay $delay $tag$suffix"


	    # Here's the test:
            test httpPipeline-${header}.${footer}${label}-${tag} $name \
            -constraints $cons \
            -setup [string map [list TE $te] {
		# Restore default values for tests:
		http::config -pipeline 1 -postfresh 0 -repost 1
                http::init
                set http::http(uid) 0
		SetTestEof {TE}
	    }] -body [list RunTest $header $footer $delay $te] -cleanup {
		# Restore default values for tests:
		http::config -pipeline 1 -postfresh 0 -repost 1
		cleanupHttpTestScript
		SetTestEof 0
		cleanupHttpTest
		after 2000
		# Wait for persistent sockets on the server to time out.
	    } -result [ReturnTestResult $header $footer $delay $te] -match $match


	  }

	}
    }
}

# ------------------------------------------------------------------------------
# (*) Notes on tests *.18*-testEof, *.19*-testEof - these test -repost 0
# ------------------------------------------------------------------------------
# These tests are a bit awkward because the main test kit analyses whether all
# requests are satisfied, with retries if necessary, and it has result analysis
# for processing retry logs.
# - *.18*-testEof tests that certain requests are NOT satisfied, so the analysis
#   is a one-off.
# - Tests *.18a-testEof depend on client/server timing - the test needs to call
#   http::geturl for all requests before the POST (request 2) is cancelled.
#   We test that requests 2, 3, 4 are all cancelled.
# - Other tests *.18*-testEof may not request 3 and 4 in time for the to be
#   added to the write queue before request 2 is completed. We simply check that
#   request 2 is cancelled.
# - The behaviour is different if all connections are allowed to time out
#   (label "j").  This case is not needed to test -repost 0, and is omitted.
# - Tests *.18*-normal and *.19* are conventional (-repost 0 should have no
#   effect).
# ------------------------------------------------------------------------------


unset header footer delay label suffix match cons name te
namespace delete ::httpTest
namespace delete ::httpTestScript

::tcltest::cleanupTests